Practical guide
Conflicts of interest and market consultation
What counts as a conflict of interest and what a contracting authority must do about it, how it may consult the market before a procedure, and how it deals with a candidate or tenderer that helped prepare the procurement.
Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte, Head of Public Sector at Closer · 20 November 2026
Legal basisRegulation 24(1) · Regulation 24(2) · Regulation 24(3) · Regulation 40(1) · Regulation 40(3) · Regulation 41(1) · Regulation 41(2) · Regulation 41(3) · Regulation 57(8)(e) · Regulation 57(8)(f) · official text
Much of what decides whether a procurement is fair happens before the contract notice is sent: who prepares it, whom the authority talks to, and what those people stand to gain. Three provisions deal with this. Regulation 24 requires contracting authorities to manage conflicts of interest; Regulation 40 allows them to consult the market before a procedure; and Regulation 41 says what happens when a candidate or tenderer has advised the authority or helped prepare the procurement. All three serve the principle that economic operators are treated equally and without discrimination (Regulation 18(1)).
Conflicts of interest
The duty
Contracting authorities must take appropriate measures to effectively prevent, identify and remedy conflicts of interest arising in the conduct of procurement procedures, so as to avoid any distortion of competition and to ensure equal treatment of all economic operators (Regulation 24(1)).
The duty has three parts, and each needs its own measures: preventing a conflict from arising, identifying one that exists, and remedying it once found. The Regulation does not list the measures; it requires that they be appropriate and effective.
What counts as a conflict
A conflict of interest includes any situation where a relevant staff member has, directly or indirectly, a financial, economic or other personal interest which might be perceived to compromise his or her impartiality and independence in the context of the procurement procedure (Regulation 24(2)).
Three features of the definition matter in practice:
- The interest may be indirect. The staff member may have it directly or indirectly.
- It need not be financial. An economic or other personal interest is enough.
- Perception is enough. The test is whether the interest might be perceived to compromise impartiality and independence, not whether it actually did.
The definition says the term "includes" these situations, so it is not necessarily exhaustive.
Who is a relevant staff member
A relevant staff member is a staff member of the contracting authority, or of a procurement service provider acting on its behalf, who is involved in the conduct of the procurement procedure or may influence its outcome (Regulation 24(3)).
Two points follow from the text. Staff of an outside procurement service provider, a body offering ancillary purchasing activities on the market (Regulation 2(1)), are covered when they act for the authority. And the test is not limited to the evaluation panel: anyone who may influence the outcome is within it.
What happens if a conflict cannot be remedied
A contracting authority may exclude an economic operator from the procedure where a conflict of interest within the meaning of Regulation 24 cannot be effectively remedied by other, less intrusive, measures (Regulation 57(8)(e)). Exclusion is therefore a last resort, after other measures have been considered. It is one of the discretionary grounds of Regulation 57(8), and may be applied at any time during the procedure where the authority becomes aware of the situation (Regulation 57(11)). The guide on exclusion grounds covers that Regulation as a whole.
Separately, an economic operator that has undertaken to unduly influence the authority's decision-making, or to obtain confidential information that may give it undue advantages in the procedure, may also be excluded (Regulation 57(8)(i)).
Recording conflicts
The written report that the authority prepares for every contract or framework agreement covered by the Regulations must include, where applicable, the conflicts of interest detected and the measures taken (Regulation 84(1)(i)). The authority must also keep documentation justifying decisions at all stages of the procedure, including communications with economic operators and internal deliberations (Regulation 84(4), Regulation 84(4)(a)), for at least 3 years from the date of award (Regulation 84(5)).
Preliminary market consultation
Before commencing a procurement procedure, a contracting authority may conduct market consultations with a view to preparing the procurement and informing economic operators of its procurement plans and requirements (Regulation 40(1)). For that purpose it may seek or accept advice from independent experts or authorities, or from market participants (Regulation 40(2)).
The advice may be used in planning and conducting the procedure, provided its use does not (Regulation 40(3)):
- have the effect of distorting competition (Regulation 40(3)(a)); or
- result in a violation of the principles of non-discrimination and transparency (Regulation 40(3)(b)).
Consultation is therefore permitted and has two purposes: preparing the procurement, and telling the market what is coming. The limit is on how the advice is used, and it is measured by effect: advice that ends up distorting competition may not be used, whatever was intended.
A practical approach that follows from these limits:
- Decide the purpose of the consultation and whom to consult, bearing in mind the duty to treat economic operators equally and without discrimination (Regulation 18(1)).
- Record what was asked, what was said and by whom (Regulation 84(4)(a)).
- Before using the advice, check whether it would favour the operator that gave it, for example through a specification only it can meet.
- If a consulted operator later takes part, apply Regulation 41.
The Regulations also treat contacting economic operators as a possible start of the procedure for valuation purposes: where no call for competition is foreseen, the estimated value is fixed when the authority commences the procedure, including, where appropriate, by contacting economic operators (Regulation 6(7)). See the guide on thresholds and estimated value.
Prior involvement of candidates or tenderers
When Regulation 41 applies
Regulation 41 applies where a candidate or tenderer, or an undertaking related to one, has advised the contracting authority, whether in a market consultation under Regulation 40 or not, or has otherwise been involved in the preparation of the procurement procedure (Regulation 41(1)). In that case the authority must take appropriate measures to ensure that competition is not distorted by the participation of that candidate or tenderer (Regulation 41(1)).
The rule reaches related undertakings, not only the candidate or tenderer itself, and covers advice given outside a formal consultation.
The minimum measures
The appropriate measures must include (Regulation 41(2)):
- communicating to the other candidates and tenderers the relevant information exchanged in the context of, or resulting from, that involvement in the preparation of the procedure (Regulation 41(2)(a)); and
- fixing adequate time limits for the receipt of tenders (Regulation 41(2)(b)).
These are a floor, not a complete list. The time limits must be adequate given the involvement concerned, which can mean longer than the minimum; the minimum time limits are in the guide on time limits.
Exclusion only as a last resort
A candidate or tenderer may be excluded under Regulation 41 only where there are no other means to ensure compliance with the duty to treat economic operators equally under Regulation 18(1) (Regulation 41(3)). Before any exclusion, it must be given the opportunity to prove that its involvement in the preparation of the procedure is not capable of distorting competition (Regulation 41(4)).
The same limit appears among the exclusion grounds: an authority may exclude an economic operator where a distortion of competition from its prior involvement in the preparation of the procedure, as referred to in Regulation 41, cannot be remedied by other, less intrusive, measures (Regulation 57(8)(f)).
The measures taken under Regulation 41 must be documented in the report under Regulation 84 (Regulation 41(5)).
Who must do what
| Situation | Contracting authority | Economic operator |
|---|---|---|
| A staff member may have a conflict | Prevent, identify and remedy it (Regulation 24(1)); record it in the report (Regulation 84(1)(i)) | Faces exclusion only if no less intrusive measure remedies it (Regulation 57(8)(e)) |
| Market consultation before the procedure | May consult and use advice, if competition is not distorted (Regulation 40(3)) | May give advice (Regulation 40(2)) |
| An adviser or preparer wants to bid | Share relevant information and set adequate time limits (Regulation 41(2)); document the measures (Regulation 41(5)) | May bid; must be heard before any exclusion (Regulation 41(4)) |
A tenderer that believes a conflict or a head start has distorted the competition has the review procedures of the Remedies Regulations (S.I. No. 130 of 2010); see the guide on remedies.
Related pages
Previous guide
Principles, contracting authorities and economic operators
Next guide
Choosing and running a procedure
Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Check does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Public Authority Contracts Regulations 2016 in force. Not legal advice.