Skip to content

Practical guide

Remedies and review

How a procurement decision is challenged under the Remedies Regulations, S.I. No. 130 of 2010, as amended: who may apply to the High Court, within what time, what an application does to the contract and what the Court may order.

Updated 20 November 2026

Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte, Head of Public Sector at Closer · 20 November 2026

Legal basisRegulation 55(1) · Regulation 55(2) · Regulation 50(1) · Regulation 33(8)(c) · Regulation 34(20) · Schedule 3 · Regulation 73 · official text

S.I. No. 284 of 2016 sets the rules for awarding a public contract, not the procedure for challenging an award. Review is governed by the European Communities (Public Authorities’ Contracts) (Review Procedures) Regulations 2010, S.I. No. 130 of 2010, referred to here as the 2010 Regulations.

This guide describes the 2010 Regulations as amended by the European Communities (Public Authorities’ Contracts) (Review Procedures) (Amendment) Regulations 2015 (S.I. No. 192 of 2015) and 2017 (S.I. No. 327 of 2017), the two instruments the Irish Statute Book’s Legislation Directory lists against them. The 2015 Regulations let the Court lift the automatic suspension of the contract; the 2017 Regulations re-pointed the 2010 Regulations from the revoked 2006 Regulations (S.I. No. 329 of 2006) to S.I. No. 284 of 2016. The Irish Statute Book publishes no consolidated text, so the amendments are read here into the text as made.

The procedure before the High Court is also governed by rules of court, which this guide does not cover. The time limits are short: take advice before acting.

Who may apply

An application is made to the High Court (Regulation 2(1) of the 2010 Regulations) by an “eligible person”: a person who has, or has had, an interest in obtaining the contract and who alleges that it has been harmed, or is at risk of being harmed, by an infringement of EU public procurement law or of Irish law transposing it (Regulation 4). Rules of court may provide for a preliminary procedure to decide whether an applicant is an eligible person (Regulation 10(1)).

A “reviewable public contract” is a contract, including a framework agreement and a dynamic purchasing system, referred to in S.I. No. 284 of 2016, the awarding of which is governed by one or more of its Parts or Chapters (Regulation 2(1), as substituted in 2017). Words used in both instruments have the meaning they have in S.I. No. 284 of 2016 (Regulation 2(5)).

What may be sought

Under Regulation 8 of the 2010 Regulations an eligible person may apply:

  • for an order to correct an alleged infringement or prevent further damage to its interests, including measures to suspend the award procedure or the implementation of a decision of the contracting authority (Regulation 8(1)(a), as amended in 2015);
  • for review of the contracting authority’s decision to award the contract to a particular tenderer or candidate (Regulation 8(1)(b));
  • where the contract has been concluded, for a declaration that it is ineffective (Regulation 8(3)).

Nothing in Regulation 8 prevents an eligible person or the contracting authority from applying for any other remedy available in the circumstances (Regulation 8(6), as amended in 2015), and the 2010 Regulations do not affect any power of the Court to grant any other remedy in relation to a contract (Regulation 14).

Before and when applying

A person intending to apply must first notify the contracting authority in writing of the alleged infringement, of its intention to apply to the Court, and of the matters that in its opinion constitute the infringement (Regulation 8(4)). Once it has applied, it must serve a copy of the originating motion on the authority as soon as reasonably practicable (Regulation 8(5)).

Time limits

Regulation 7 of the 2010 Regulations sets these periods:

ApplicationPeriodProvision (2010)
Interlocutory orders, or review of the award decision30 calendar days after the applicant was notified of the decision, or knew or ought to have known of the infringement7(2)
Ineffectiveness, where a contract award notice was published under Regulation 50 and Regulation 51 (and, for a contract awarded without a prior contract notice, it sets out the justification for not publishing one)30 calendar days from the day after publication in the Official Journal7(3)(a), 7(4)
Ineffectiveness, where each tenderer and candidate concerned was notified of the outcome with a summary of reasons complying with Regulation 6(2)30 calendar days from the day after that notice7(3)(b), 7(5)
Ineffectiveness of a contract based on a framework agreement or a dynamic purchasing system, where notice was given under Regulation 6(2)30 calendar days from the day after that notice7(3)(c), 7(5)
Ineffectiveness, in any other case6 months after the conclusion of the contract7(6)

Rules of court may allow the Court to grant leave, if it considers that there is good reason, to apply after the time permitted by Regulation 7(2) (Regulation 10(2)); the provision mentions only Regulation 7(2), not the periods for ineffectiveness.

The first period runs from notification of the decision or knowledge of the infringement. Regulation 5A, inserted in 2017, provides that nothing in Regulations 5 and 6 of the 2010 Regulations affects Regulation 55, in particular the reasons a tenderer may request within 15 days under Regulation 55(2); neither instrument says that such a request moves the start of the period. Do not assume the period waits for the answer.

What an application does to the contract

If a person applies to the Court under Regulation 8(1), the contracting authority must not conclude the contract until the Court has determined the matter, the Court gives leave to lift any suspension, or the proceedings are discontinued or otherwise disposed of (Regulation 8(2), as substituted in 2015). This applies on top of the standstill period, during which the contract may not be concluded either (Regulation 5(1)); the guide on award and standstill explains that period and the notice that starts it.

Since 2015 the suspension is no longer absolute. On an application by the contracting authority, the Court may make an order permitting it to conclude the contract before the matter is determined (Regulations 8(2A) and 8A). The Court must first consider whether, if the suspension did not apply, it would be appropriate to grant an injunction restraining the authority from entering into the contract, and may make the order only if it would not (Regulation 8A(2)). The order may be made subject to conditions (Regulation 8A(3)), and the authority must serve a copy of its originating motion on the eligible person as soon as reasonably practicable (Regulation 8A(4)). Nothing in the 2010 Regulations, however, enables the Court to permit the contract to be concluded during the standstill period itself (Regulation 5(5)).

Regulation 11(1) names a contract concluded during the standstill period a “Regulation 5(1) infringement”, and a contract concluded after a tenderer or candidate applied for review of the award decision but before the Court decided a “Regulation 8(2) infringement”. A contract concluded under an order of the Court made under Regulation 8A, and in compliance with any conditions it sets, is not a Regulation 8(2) infringement (Regulation 11(1A)). Both kinds of infringement matter for ineffectiveness, below.

The Court’s powers

Regulation 9 of the 2010 Regulations gives the Court power to:

  • set aside, vary or affirm a decision to which the 2010 Regulations apply (9(1)(a));
  • declare a contract ineffective and impose alternative penalties, with any necessary consequential order (9(1)(b) and (c));
  • make interlocutory orders, including measures to suspend the award procedure or the implementation of a decision (9(2));
  • set aside any discriminatory technical, economic or financial specification in an invitation to tender, contract document or other document relating to the award procedure (9(3));
  • suspend the operation of a decision or a contract by order (9(5));
  • award damages as compensation for loss resulting from a decision that infringes EU law or Irish law transposing it (9(6)).

When considering an interim or interlocutory order, the Court may take into account the probable consequences for all interests likely to be harmed and the public interest, and may decline to make an order whose negative consequences could exceed its benefits (9(4)).

Ineffectiveness

When the Court must declare a contract ineffective

Subject to the exceptions below, Regulation 11(2) of the 2010 Regulations requires a declaration of ineffectiveness in three cases:

  1. the contract was concluded without first publishing a contract notice in the Official Journal, where that was not permitted;
  2. the contract was concluded during the standstill period or while a review application was pending, where this deprived the applicant of the possibility of pursuing pre-contractual remedies and was combined with an infringement that affected the applicant’s chances of obtaining the contract;
  3. a contract based on a framework agreement or a dynamic purchasing system awarded in breach of the rules for reopening competition under a framework agreement (Regulation 33(8)(c)) or for awards under a dynamic purchasing system (Regulation 34(20) to Regulation 34(23)), where the contract’s value equals or exceeds the relevant threshold in Regulation 5 (Regulation 11(2)(c), as amended in 2017).

In other cases of a contract concluded during the standstill period or while an application was pending, the Court may declare the contract ineffective after assessing all relevant aspects (Regulation 11(7)).

The exceptions

The first case does not apply where the contracting authority considered that an award without a prior contract notice was permitted, published in the Official Journal a notice of its intention to conclude the contract, with the content set out in Regulation 11(8), and did not conclude the contract before the end of 14 calendar days from the day after that publication (Regulation 11(3)). The notice must include a justification for the decision not to publish a contract notice. The grounds on which S.I. No. 284 of 2016 permits that route are in Regulation 32; see the guide on the negotiated procedure without publication.

The third case does not apply where the authority considered the award in accordance with those rules, sent the tenderers concerned a notice of the award decision with a summary of reasons, and waited 14 days (fax or electronic means) or 16 days (other means) from the day after sending it (Regulation 11(4)).

The Court may also decline to declare a contract ineffective if overriding reasons relating to a general interest require that its effects be maintained (Regulation 11(5)). Economic interests in the contract’s effectiveness count only where, in exceptional circumstances, ineffectiveness would lead to disproportionate consequences; economic interests directly linked to the contract, such as the costs of delay, of a new procedure, of changing contractor and of legal obligations resulting from ineffectiveness, are not overriding reasons (Regulation 11(6)).

Effect of a declaration

If the Court declares a contract ineffective, contractual obligations not yet performed are cancelled; those already performed are not affected (Regulation 12(1)). The Court may make any order necessary in the interests of justice to ensure proper payment for work done, or goods or services provided, in good faith in reliance on the contract (Regulation 11(9)).

Alternative penalties

The Court must impose an alternative penalty where it declines to declare a contract ineffective on general-interest grounds, or where it finds that an infringement under Regulation 11(7) occurred but declines to declare the contract ineffective (Regulation 13(1)). The penalty is either or both of:

  • a civil financial penalty on the contracting authority of up to 10 per cent of the value of the contract, paid into the Central Fund;
  • the termination, or shortening of the duration, of the contract (Regulation 13(2) and (4)).

The Court may take into account all relevant factors, including the seriousness of the infringement, the behaviour of the contracting authority and the extent to which the contract remains in force, and needs to be satisfied of the facts only on the balance of probabilities (Regulation 13(3)). An award of damages is not an appropriate alternative penalty (Regulation 13(6)).

Where S.I. No. 284 of 2016 meets the review rules

  • The contracting authority must inform each candidate and tenderer of its decision as soon as possible (Regulation 55(1)) and, on written request, give reasons within 15 days (Regulation 55(2)).
  • Contract notices and contract award notices name the body responsible for review and give precise information on the deadlines for review, or the service from which that information may be obtained (Schedule 3); the award notice is sent within 30 days of the award (Regulation 50(1)).
  • The authority’s documentation must justify decisions at all stages of the procedure (Regulation 84(4)).
  • Every contract must allow the authority to terminate it in the cases listed in Regulation 73, including where the contractor should have been excluded.

Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Check does it.

Request a demo

General information on the Public Authority Contracts Regulations 2016 in force. Not legal advice.