Practical guide
Choosing and running a procedure
Which award procedures a contracting authority may use, when the competitive procedure with negotiation and the competitive dialogue are available, and how each procedure runs from the call for competition to the award.
Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte, Head of Public Sector at Closer · 20 November 2026
Legal basisRegulation 26(1) · Regulation 26(2) · Regulation 26(3) · Regulation 26(4) · Regulation 26(10) · Regulation 27(1) · Regulation 28(1) · Regulation 29(2) · Regulation 29(8) · Regulation 29(9) · Regulation 30(1) · Regulation 30(4) · Regulation 31(1) · Regulation 31(2) · Regulation 65 · official text
The Regulations give a contracting authority five procedures that begin with a published call for competition: the open procedure, the restricted procedure, the competitive procedure with negotiation, the competitive dialogue and the innovation partnership. A sixth, the negotiated procedure without prior publication, is an exception with its own guide. Regulation 26 says which procedure may be chosen and when; Regulations 27 to 31 say how each one runs. The text described here is S.I. No. 284 of 2016 as amended by S.I. No. 203 of 2017, the only amending instrument the Irish Statute Book’s Legislation Directory lists.
Choosing a procedure
When awarding public contracts, a contracting authority applies procedures that conform to the Regulations where, without prejudice to Regulation 32, a call for competition has been published in accordance with them (Regulation 26(1)). It may apply open or restricted procedures, or innovation partnerships, as provided for in the Regulations (Regulation 26(2)). Regulation 26 sets no further situations for these three.
The competitive procedure with negotiation and the competitive dialogue are different: a contracting authority may apply them only in the situations listed in Regulation 26(3). The first group concerns works, supplies or services fulfilling one or more of these criteria (Regulation 26(3)(a)):
- the needs of the contracting authority cannot be met without adaptation of readily available solutions (Regulation 26(3)(a)(i));
- they include design or innovative solutions (Regulation 26(3)(a)(ii));
- the contract cannot be awarded without prior negotiation because of specific circumstances related to the nature, the complexity or the legal and financial make-up, or because of risks attaching to them (Regulation 26(3)(a)(iii));
- the technical specifications cannot be established with sufficient precision by reference to a standard, European Technical Assessment, common technical specification or technical reference (Regulation 26(3)(a)(iv)).
The second situation is where, in response to an open or a restricted procedure, only irregular or unacceptable tenders are submitted (Regulation 26(3)(b)). Tenders that do not comply with the procurement documents, were received late, show evidence of collusion or corruption, or have been found to be abnormally low are irregular (Regulation 26(5)). Tenders submitted by tenderers without the required qualifications, or whose price exceeds the authority’s budget as determined and documented before the procedure was launched, are unacceptable (Regulation 26(6)).
In that second situation the authority need not publish a contract notice if it includes in the new procedure all of, and only, the tenderers which satisfy the criteria of Regulations 57 to 64 and which, in the earlier open or restricted procedure, submitted tenders in accordance with its formal requirements (Regulation 26(4)).
Whichever of these two procedures is used, the written report on the procurement must give the circumstances referred to in Regulation 26 which justify it (Regulation 84(1)(e)).
The call for competition
The call for competition is made by a contract notice in accordance with Regulation 49 (Regulation 26(7)). Where the contract is awarded by restricted procedure or competitive procedure with negotiation, a sub-central contracting authority may instead make the call by a prior information notice (Regulation 26(8)); operators which express interest are then sent an invitation to confirm interest (Regulation 26(9)). Both routes are explained in the guide on notices and procurement documents.
The negotiated procedure without prior publication of a call for competition may be used only in the cases of Regulation 32 (Regulation 26(10)): see the guide on the negotiated procedure without prior publication.
The procedures side by side
| Open | Restricted | Competitive procedure with negotiation | Competitive dialogue | Innovation partnership | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who may tender or take part | Any interested economic operator (Regulation 27(1)(a)) | Only operators invited after assessment (Regulation 28(1)(c)) | Only operators invited after assessment (Regulation 29(6)) | Only operators invited after assessment (Regulation 30(1)(c)) | Only operators invited after assessment (Regulation 31(1)(f)) |
| Minimum time for requests to participate | None: one stage | 30 days (Regulation 28(1)(b)) | 30 days (Regulation 29(4)) | 30 days (Regulation 30(1)(b)) | 30 days (Regulation 31(1)(e)) |
| Minimum time for tenders | 35 days (Regulation 27(1)(b)) | 30 days (Regulation 28(1)(e)) | 30 days for initial tenders (Regulation 29(5)) | None set in Regulation 30 | None set in Regulation 31 |
| Minimum number of candidates if the number is limited | Not applicable | 5 (Regulation 65(3)) | 3 (Regulation 65(4)) | 3 (Regulation 65(4)) | 3 (Regulation 65(4)) |
| Negotiation or dialogue | Not provided for in Regulation 27 | Not provided for in Regulation 28 | On initial and later tenders, not final ones (Regulation 29(8)) | On all aspects of the procurement (Regulation 30(1)(h)(ii)) | On initial and later tenders, not the final one (Regulation 31(6)) |
| Award basis | Most economically advantageous tender (Regulation 67(1)) | Same | Award criteria set in the procurement documents (Regulation 29(2)(b)) | Best price-quality ratio only (Regulation 30(1)(e)) | Best price-quality ratio only (Regulation 31(1)(h)) |
The time limits above are minimums and can be shortened or must be extended in some cases; the guide on time limits for tenders sets them out, and the time limits table lists them.
Open procedure
Any interested economic operator may submit a tender in response to the call for competition (Regulation 27(1)(a)). The tender must be accompanied by the information for qualitative selection that the contracting authority requests (Regulation 27(1)(c)), so there is no separate stage for requests to participate.
Restricted procedure
An economic operator submits a request to participate, providing the information for qualitative selection the authority requests (Regulation 28(1)(a)). Only those invited by the authority after assessing that information may tender (Regulation 28(1)(c)). The authority may limit the number of suitable candidates it invites in accordance with Regulation 65 (Regulation 28(1)(d)): it must state in the contract notice or the invitation to confirm interest the objective and non-discriminatory criteria it will use and the minimum (and any maximum) number (Regulation 65(2)), and the number invited must be sufficient to ensure genuine competition (Regulation 65(5)). Invitations go to the selected candidates simultaneously and in writing (Regulation 54(1)).
Competitive procedure with negotiation
In the procurement documents the authority identifies the subject matter by describing its needs and the characteristics required, specifies the award criteria, and indicates which elements of the description are minimum requirements that all tenders must meet (Regulation 29(2)). That information must be precise enough for operators to identify the nature and scope of the procurement and decide whether to request to participate (Regulation 29(3)).
Only invited operators may submit an initial tender, which is the basis for the negotiations (Regulation 29(6)). The authority negotiates the initial and all later tenders, except the final tenders, to improve their content (Regulation 29(8)). The minimum requirements and the award criteria are not negotiable (Regulation 29(9)). If it reserved the possibility in the contract notice or invitation to confirm interest, the authority may award on the initial tenders without negotiating (Regulation 29(10)).
During negotiations the authority must treat all tenderers equally: no discriminatory information, written notice of changes to the documents to all tenderers still in the procedure, and enough time to resubmit (Regulation 29(11)). It may not reveal a participant’s confidential information without that participant’s agreement, given for specific information rather than as a general waiver (Regulation 29(12), Regulation 29(13)).
Negotiations may take place in successive stages, reducing the number of tenders by applying the award criteria (Regulation 29(14)); the authority must say in advance whether it will do so (Regulation 29(15)). To close, it informs the remaining tenderers and sets a common deadline for new or revised tenders, verifies that the final tenders meet the minimum requirements, assesses them on the award criteria and awards under Regulations 66 to 69 (Regulation 29(16)).
Competitive dialogue
Operators request to participate in response to a contract notice (Regulation 30(1)(a)), and only those invited may take part in the dialogue (Regulation 30(1)(c)). The authority sets out its needs and requirements in the contract notice, a descriptive document or both, together with the award criteria and an indicative timeframe (Regulation 30(1)(f), Regulation 30(1)(g)).
The aim of the dialogue is to identify and define the means best suited to satisfying the authority’s needs, and all aspects of the procurement may be discussed (Regulation 30(1)(h)). Equal treatment and confidentiality apply as in negotiation (Regulation 30(1)(i), Regulation 30(1)(j), Regulation 30(1)(k)). The dialogue may run in successive stages if announced (Regulation 30(2)) and continues until the authority can identify the solution or solutions capable of meeting its needs (Regulation 30(3)).
The authority then declares the dialogue concluded and asks the remaining participants for final tenders containing all the elements required for performance (Regulation 30(4)(a), Regulation 30(4)(b)). These may be clarified, specified and optimised, but not changed in essential aspects where that is likely to distort competition or discriminate (Regulation 30(4)(c)). After assessment on the award criteria, the authority may negotiate with the tenderer offering the best price-quality ratio to confirm financial commitments or other terms, within the same limits (Regulation 30(5)). Prizes or payments to participants may be specified (Regulation 30(6)).
Innovation partnership
The procurement documents identify a need for an innovative product, service or works that cannot be met by purchasing what is already available on the market, and the minimum requirements (Regulation 31(1)(b)). The partnership aims to develop that innovation and then purchase the result, if it corresponds to the performance levels and maximum costs agreed (Regulation 31(2)). It may be set up with one partner or several conducting separate research and development (Regulation 31(1)(d)).
In selecting candidates the authority applies criteria on their capacity in research and development and in developing and implementing innovative solutions (Regulation 31(10)). The partnership is structured in successive phases with intermediate targets and remuneration in instalments (Regulation 31(3), Regulation 31(4)); after each phase the authority may terminate it or, with several partners, reduce their number, where the procurement documents said so and set the conditions (Regulation 31(5)). Tenders are negotiated as in the competitive procedure with negotiation (Regulation 31(6), Regulation 31(7)). The documents must define the arrangements for intellectual property rights (Regulation 31(12)), and the estimated value of what is purchased must not be disproportionate to the investment required to develop it (Regulation 31(15)).
Keeping the record
For every procedure, the authority keeps documentation recording its progress and justifying decisions at all stages, including any dialogue or negotiation (Regulation 84(4)). A first check of whether the Regulations apply at all is the estimated value against the thresholds.
Related pages
Previous guide
Conflicts of interest and market consultation
Next guide
Negotiated procedure without prior publication
Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Check does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Public Authority Contracts Regulations 2016 in force. Not legal advice.