Practical guide
Abnormally low tenders
What a contracting authority must do when a tender appears abnormally low: ask for an explanation, assess it with the tenderer, and reject the tender only on the grounds Regulation 69 allows or requires.
Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte, Head of Public Sector at Closer · 20 November 2026
Legal basisRegulation 69(1) · Regulation 69(2) · Regulation 69(3) · Regulation 69(4) · Regulation 69(5) · Regulation 69(6) · Regulation 69(7) · Regulation 18(4)(a) · Regulation 84(1)(c) · official text
A tender with a very low price can be the best value a contracting authority will see, or a sign that the contract cannot be performed at that price, or performed lawfully. Regulation 69 does not let the authority guess which. It requires the authority to ask the tenderer to explain, to assess the explanation with the tenderer, and to reject the tender only where the explanation does not account for the low price, or where the low price comes from a breach of environmental, social or labour law obligations. A separate rule covers tenders made low by State aid.
When the rule is triggered
The trigger is a tender that appears to be abnormally low in relation to the works, supplies or services (Regulation 69(1)). The Regulations do not define “abnormally low” and set no formula, percentage or comparison with other tenders or with the estimated value. Whether a tender appears abnormally low is a judgment the authority makes on the facts of the procurement, and it should record how it reached it (Regulation 84(4)).
The comparison is with the works, supplies or services: what is being bought, at the level of price or costs proposed. The rule covers both the price and the costs proposed in the tender (Regulation 69(1)), so it can apply where the contract is awarded on cost, including life-cycle costing, and not only on price; see the guide on award criteria and life-cycle costing.
Step 1: the authority must ask for an explanation
Where a tender appears abnormally low, the authority shall require the economic operator to explain the price or costs proposed (Regulation 69(1)). This is a duty, not an option: an authority that considers a tender abnormally low may not set it aside without first asking.
The explanation may relate, amongst other things, to (Regulation 69(2)):
| Subject | Provision |
|---|---|
| The economics of the manufacturing process, of the services provided or of the construction method | Regulation 69(2)(a) |
| The technical solutions chosen, or exceptionally favourable conditions available to the tenderer for supplying the products or services or executing the work | Regulation 69(2)(b) |
| The originality of the work, supplies or services proposed | Regulation 69(2)(c) |
| Compliance with applicable environmental, social and labour law obligations under Regulation 18(4) | Regulation 69(2)(d) |
| Compliance with the obligations referred to in Regulation 71 on subcontracting | Regulation 69(2)(e) |
| The possibility of the tenderer obtaining State aid | Regulation 69(2)(f) |
The list is open. A tenderer may rely on any element that accounts for its price, and the authority should frame its request so that the tenderer knows which parts of the price or costs cause concern.
Step 2: assessing the explanation with the tenderer
The authority must assess the information provided by consulting the tenderer (Regulation 69(3)). The tenderer is therefore heard in the assessment itself, and not only asked for a written explanation at the start; if the explanation raises further questions, it is sensible to put them to the tenderer before deciding.
Any request must respect the general principles: equal treatment and non-discrimination, transparency and proportionality (Regulation 18(1)).
Step 3: the decision
There are three outcomes, and the Regulations govern each.
The explanation is satisfactory
The tender stays in the competition and is evaluated against the award criteria like any other (Regulation 56(1)).
The explanation does not account for the low price: rejection is allowed
The authority may only reject the tender where the evidence supplied does not satisfactorily account for the low level of price or costs proposed, taking into account the elements listed in paragraph (2) (Regulation 69(4)). The word “only” limits the authority: a low price that has been satisfactorily explained is not a ground for rejection under Regulation 69.
The low price comes from a breach of social, environmental or labour law: rejection is required
The authority shall reject a tender where it has established that the tender is abnormally low because it does not comply with applicable obligations referred to in Regulation 18(4) (Regulation 69(5)). Those are the obligations in the fields of environmental, social and labour law that apply at the place where the works are carried out or the services provided, established by European Union law, national law, collective agreements or the international conventions listed in Schedule 7 (Regulation 18(4)(a), Schedule 7).
This is linked to a wider rule at award: the authority may decide not to award the contract to the tenderer with the most economically advantageous tender where it has established that the tender does not comply with those obligations (Regulation 56(2)).
State aid
A tender may be low because the tenderer has obtained State aid. Where the authority establishes that this is why the tender is abnormally low, it may reject the tender on that ground alone only (Regulation 69(6)):
- after consultation with the tenderer concerned (Regulation 69(6)(a)), and
- where the tenderer is unable to prove, within a sufficient time limit fixed by the authority, that the aid was compatible with the internal market within the meaning of Article 107 of the TFEU (Regulation 69(6)(b)).
An authority that rejects a tender on this ground must inform the Commission in writing (Regulation 69(7)).
Recording and reporting the decision
The written report the authority prepares for every contract must include the reasons for the rejection of tenders found to be abnormally low (Regulation 84(1)(c)). The authority must also keep documentation justifying its decisions at all stages of the procedure, including communications with economic operators and internal deliberations (Regulation 84(4)), for at least 3 years from the date of award (Regulation 84(5)).
A tenderer whose tender is rejected may ask in writing for the reasons, and the authority must give them as soon as possible and no later than 15 days after the request (Regulation 55(2)(b)).
Consequences elsewhere in the procedure
A tender found by the authority to be abnormally low is considered irregular in two places in the Regulations:
- If an open or restricted procedure produces only irregular or unacceptable tenders, the authority may move to a competitive procedure with negotiation or a competitive dialogue (Regulation 26(3)(b)), and tenders found to be abnormally low count as irregular for that purpose (Regulation 26(5)(d)). In that case it need not publish a new contract notice if it includes all of, and only, the tenderers that satisfy the exclusion and selection criteria and submitted tenders in accordance with the formal requirements of the prior procedure (Regulation 26(4)).
- Before an electronic auction, only admissible tenders are invited, and tenders found to be abnormally low are irregular and so not admissible (Regulation 35(10)(b), Regulation 35(11)(d)).
For the tenderer
- If asked to explain your price or costs, answer with evidence: costings, the method or technical solution behind the price, supplier terms, and how you meet employment, environmental and subcontracting obligations.
- Address each concern the authority raises; the assessment is made on the evidence supplied (Regulation 69(4)).
- If State aid is part of the explanation, be ready to prove, within the time limit set, that it was compatible with the internal market (Regulation 69(6)(b)).
- If the tender is rejected, ask for the reasons in writing (Regulation 55(2)(b)). Review of procurement decisions is governed by the Remedies Regulations (S.I. No. 130 of 2010), not by S.I. No. 284 of 2016; see the guide on remedies.
For the authority
- Identify the tenders that appear abnormally low and record why.
- Write to each tenderer concerned asking it to explain its price or costs, naming the points of concern (Regulation 69(1)).
- Consult the tenderer on its explanation before deciding (Regulation 69(3)).
- Reject only on the grounds in Regulation 69(4), Regulation 69(5) or Regulation 69(6), and inform the Commission in a State aid case (Regulation 69(7)).
- Put the reasons for any rejection in the report under Regulation 84(1).
Related pages
Previous guide
Award criteria and life-cycle costing
Next guide
Framework agreements, dynamic purchasing and e-tools
Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Check does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Public Authority Contracts Regulations 2016 in force. Not legal advice.