Skip to content

FAQ

Award criteria

On what basis a contract is awarded, which award criteria may be used, how they are linked to the subject matter and weighted, how life-cycle costing works and what happens to an abnormally low tender.

Updated 20 November 202610 questions

Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte, Head of Public Sector at Closer · 20 November 2026

These answers are on S.I. No. 284 of 2016, as amended by S.I. No. 203 of 2017.

On what basis is a contract awarded?

On the most economically advantageous tender, without prejudice to any law in the State on the price of certain supplies or the remuneration of certain services (Regulation 67(1)). That tender is identified on the basis of the price or cost, using a cost-effectiveness approach, including life-cycle costing, and may include the best price-quality ratio (Regulation 67(2)). The guide on award criteria explains each approach.

Legal basisRegulation 67(1) · Regulation 67(2) · official text

May a contracting authority award on price alone?

Yes. The most economically advantageous tender is identified on the basis of the price or cost and may, but need not, include the best price-quality ratio (Regulation 67(2)). Where it is identified on price alone, no weighting has to be stated (Regulation 67(9)).

Legal basisRegulation 67(2) · Regulation 67(9) · official text

What criteria may be used for the best price-quality ratio?

Criteria linked to the subject matter, including qualitative, environmental or social aspects (Regulation 67(2)). They may comprise, amongst other things, quality, accessibility and environmental or innovative characteristics; the organisation, qualification and experience of the staff assigned, where their quality can significantly affect performance; and after-sales service, technical assistance and delivery conditions (Regulation 67(3)).

Legal basisRegulation 67(2) · Regulation 67(3) · official text

Can tenderers compete on quality alone?

Yes. The cost element may take the form of a fixed price or cost, on the basis of which economic operators compete on quality criteria only (Regulation 67(4)).

Legal basisRegulation 67(4) · official text

When is an award criterion linked to the subject matter of the contract?

When it relates to the works, supplies or services to be provided under the contract in any respect and at any stage of their life cycle, including factors in the specific process of production, provision or trading, or in a process for another stage of the life cycle (Regulation 67(5)).

Legal basisRegulation 67(5) · official text

What limits apply to award criteria?

They must not confer an unrestricted freedom of choice on the authority (Regulation 67(6)). They must ensure the possibility of effective competition and be accompanied by specifications that allow the information given by tenderers to be effectively verified (Regulation 67(7)); in case of doubt, the authority must verify that information (Regulation 67(8)).

Legal basisRegulation 67(6) · Regulation 67(7) · Regulation 67(8) · official text

Where must the weighting of the award criteria be stated?

In the procurement documents: the authority specifies the relative weighting it gives to each criterion, unless the tender is identified on price alone (Regulation 67(9)). The weighting may be a range with an appropriate maximum spread (Regulation 67(10)); where weighting is not possible for objective reasons, the criteria are listed in descending order of importance (Regulation 67(11)).

Legal basisRegulation 67(9) · Regulation 67(10) · Regulation 67(11) · official text

What must the documents say if life-cycle costing is used?

The data the tenderers must provide and the method the authority will use to determine the life-cycle costs from that data (Regulation 68(4)). The costs may include acquisition, use, maintenance and end of life, and environmental externalities whose monetary value can be determined and verified (Regulation 68(1)). Where an EU act listed in Schedule 9 makes a common method mandatory, that method applies (Regulation 68(5), Schedule 9).

Legal basisRegulation 68(4) · Regulation 68(1) · Regulation 68(5) · Schedule 9 · official text

What happens if a tender appears abnormally low?

The authority must require the tenderer to explain the price or costs proposed (Regulation 69(1)) and assess the explanation by consulting the tenderer (Regulation 69(3)). It may reject the tender only where the evidence does not satisfactorily account for the low price or costs (Regulation 69(4)), and must reject it where the low price results from non-compliance with environmental, social or labour law obligations (Regulation 69(5)). See the guide on abnormally low tenders.

Legal basisRegulation 69(1) · Regulation 69(3) · Regulation 69(4) · Regulation 69(5) · official text

What can an unsuccessful tenderer learn about the winning tender?

A tenderer that made an admissible tender may ask in writing for the characteristics and relative advantages of the tender selected and the name of the successful tenderer; the authority must reply as soon as possible and within 15 days of the request (Regulation 55(2)(c)), subject to the grounds for withholding information in Regulation 55(3).

Legal basisRegulation 55(2)(c) · Regulation 55(3) · official text

Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Check does it.

Request a demo

General information on the Public Authority Contracts Regulations 2016 in force. Not legal advice.