# Selection criteria

- URL: https://procurelex.ie/guides/selection-criteria
- Updated 2026-11-20
- Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte (Head of Public Sector at Closer), 2026-11-20
- Legal basis: Regulation 58(1), Regulation 58(4), Regulation 58(9), Regulation 58(20), Regulation 60(1), Regulation 62(1), Regulation 63(1), Regulation 64(2), Regulation 65(1), Schedule 8

What a contracting authority may require of economic operators to take part in a procedure: suitability, economic and financial standing, technical and professional ability, the means of proof, reliance on other entities and the reduction of candidates.

[Selection criteria](https://procurelex.ie/glossary/selection-criteria) decide whether an economic operator that is not excluded is capable of performing the contract. They look at the operator, not at its tender; award criteria then compare the tenders. This guide covers what Regulation 58 allows an authority to ask, how it is proved (Regulations 60 and 62 and Schedule 8), reliance on other entities (Regulation 63), official lists (Regulation 64) and the reduction of the number of candidates (Regulation 65).

The text described here is S.I. No. 284 of 2016 as amended by S.I. No. 203 of 2017, the only amending instrument the Irish Statute Book’s Legislation Directory lists.

## The three categories and their limits

Selection criteria may relate to three things ([Regulation 58(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p1)):

1. suitability to pursue a professional activity;
2. economic and financial standing;
3. technical and professional ability.

The authority may impose only the criteria set out in paragraphs (5) to (19) of Regulation 58 ([Regulation 58(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p2)). Requirements must be limited to those appropriate to ensure that a candidate or tenderer has the legal and financial capacities and the technical and professional abilities to perform the contract ([Regulation 58(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p3)), and all of them must be related, and proportionate, to the subject matter of the contract ([Regulation 58(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p4)).

The requirements, which may be expressed as minimum levels of ability, and the means of proof must be indicated in the contract notice or the [invitation to confirm interest](https://procurelex.ie/glossary/invitation-to-confirm-interest) ([Regulation 58(20)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p20)).

## Suitability to pursue a professional activity

The authority may require enrolment in one of the professional or trade registers of the operator’s Member State of establishment, as specified in Annex XI to the Public Authorities Contracts Directive, or compliance with any other request specified in that Annex ([Regulation 58(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p5)).

For services, where an operator needs a particular authorisation or membership of a particular organisation to perform the service in its country of origin, the authority may require proof that it holds it ([Regulation 58(6)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p6)).

## Economic and financial standing

The authority may impose requirements ensuring that the operator has the economic and financial capacity to perform the contract ([Regulation 58(7)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p7)). It may require ([Regulation 58(8)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p8)):

- a certain minimum yearly turnover, including a minimum turnover in the area covered by the contract;
- information on annual accounts showing ratios, such as the ratio between assets and liabilities;
- an appropriate level of professional risk indemnity insurance.

### The turnover cap

The minimum yearly turnover required must not exceed twice the estimated contract value ([Regulation 58(9)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p9)). The exception is duly justified cases, including special risks attached to the nature of the works, services or supplies; the authority must then indicate its main reasons in the procurement documents or in its procurement report under Regulation 84(1).

The cap is applied to the right unit:

| Situation                                                                   | Basis for the cap                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| --------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| Contract divided into lots                                                  | Each lot ([Regulation 58(12)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p12)); the authority may also set the turnover by reference to groups of lots where the successful tenderer is awarded several lots to be executed at the same time ([Regulation 58(13)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p13)) |
| Framework agreement with contracts awarded after a reopening of competition | The expected maximum size of specific contracts performed at the same time or, if not known, the estimated value of the framework agreement ([Regulation 58(14)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p14))                                            |
| Dynamic purchasing system                                                   | The expected maximum size of specific contracts to be awarded under the system ([Regulation 58(15)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p15))                                                                                                         |

### Ratios

A ratio between assets and liabilities may be taken into consideration only where the authority specifies the methods and criteria for doing so in the procurement documents ([Regulation 58(10)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p10)), and those methods and criteria must be transparent, objective and non-discriminatory ([Regulation 58(11)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p11)).

## Technical and professional ability

The authority may impose requirements ensuring that the operator has the human and technical resources and experience needed to perform the contract to an appropriate quality standard ([Regulation 58(16)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p16)). It may require a sufficient level of experience shown by suitable references from past contracts ([Regulation 58(17)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p17)).

For supplies requiring siting or installation work, and for services or works, professional ability may be evaluated with regard to the operator’s skills, efficiency, experience and reliability ([Regulation 58(19)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p19)).

The authority may assume that an operator lacks the required professional abilities where it has established that the operator has conflicting interests which may negatively affect the performance of the contract ([Regulation 58(18)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/58#p18)).

In service and works contracts, and supply contracts that also cover services or siting and installation, legal persons may be required to name the staff responsible for performance and give their qualifications ([Regulation 19(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/19#p2)).

## Means of proof

The authority may require the certificates, statements and other means of proof in Regulation 60 and Schedule 8 as evidence that selection criteria are met ([Regulation 60(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/60#p1)). It may not require means of proof other than those in Regulation 60 and Regulation 62 ([Regulation 60(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/60#p2)).

**Economic and financial standing** may be proved by one or more of the references in Part 1 of Schedule 8 ([Regulation 60(6)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/60#p6), [Schedule 8](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/schedule-8)): appropriate bank statements or evidence of professional risk indemnity insurance; financial statements or extracts, where their publication is required in the operator’s country; and a statement of overall turnover and, where appropriate, turnover in the area of the contract for at most the last 3 financial years available. If an operator cannot, for any valid reason, provide the references requested, it may prove its standing by any other document the authority considers appropriate ([Regulation 60(7)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/60#p7)).

**Technical ability** may be proved by one or more of the means in Part 2 of Schedule 8 ([Regulation 60(8)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/60#p8), [Schedule 8](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/schedule-8)). They include a list of works over at most the past 5 years, or of principal deliveries or main services over at most the past 3 years (older evidence may be taken into account where the authority indicates this is necessary for an adequate level of competition); the technicians, technical facilities, quality measures and supply chain systems; educational and professional qualifications, provided they are not evaluated as an award criterion; environmental management measures, manpower and equipment; the proportion of the contract the operator may subcontract; and, for products, samples and certificates of conformity.

At the time of submission, the operator does not file these documents: it gives an [ESPD](https://procurelex.ie/glossary/espd), and the documents are requested later. See the [guide to the ESPD](https://procurelex.ie/guides/espd).

## Quality assurance and environmental management standards

Where the authority asks for certificates from independent bodies on quality assurance standards, including on accessibility for disabled persons, it must refer to systems based on the relevant European standards series certified by accredited bodies ([Regulation 62(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/62#p1)). For environmental management, it must refer to EMAS, other systems recognised under Article 45 of Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009, or other standards based on the relevant European or international standards ([Regulation 62(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/62#p4)).

In both cases it must recognise equivalent certificates from bodies in other Member States ([Regulation 62(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/62#p2), [Regulation 62(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/62#p4)), and accept other evidence of equivalent measures where the operator could not obtain the certificates within the time limits for reasons not attributable to it ([Regulation 62(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/62#p3), [Regulation 62(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/62#p5)).

## Relying on other entities

For economic and financial standing and technical and professional ability, an operator may, where appropriate and for a particular contract, rely on the capacities of other entities, whatever the legal nature of its links with them ([Regulation 63(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/63#p1)). Suitability to pursue a professional activity is not among the criteria listed there.

- **Qualifications and experience.** For educational and professional qualifications under Part 2(f) of Schedule 8, or relevant professional experience, it may rely on others only where they will perform the works or services for which those capacities are required ([Regulation 63(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/63#p2)).
- **Proof of availability.** It must prove that it will have the resources at its disposal, for example by producing a commitment from those entities ([Regulation 63(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/63#p3)); any appropriate means may be used ([Regulation 60(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/60#p3)).
- **Checks on the entity.** The authority verifies whether those entities meet the relevant selection criteria and whether there are grounds for exclusion. It must require replacement of an entity that fails a criterion or is subject to a compulsory ground, and may require substitution of one subject to a non-compulsory ground ([Regulation 63(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/63#p4)).
- **Joint liability.** Where reliance concerns economic and financial standing, the authority may require joint liability for the execution of the contract ([Regulation 63(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/63#p5)).
- **Critical tasks.** In works contracts, service contracts and siting or installation operations under a supply contract, the authority may require certain critical tasks to be performed directly by the tenderer or by a participant in the group ([Regulation 63(7)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/63#p7)).

A group of economic operators may rely on the capacities of its participants or of other entities on the same terms ([Regulation 63(6)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/63#p6)), and the authority may clarify in the procurement documents how groups are to meet the requirements, where justified by objective reasons and proportionate ([Regulation 19(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/19#p4)).

## Official lists and certification

An operator registered on an official list or certified by a certification body may submit that certificate for each contract ([Regulation 64(1)(a)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/64#p1-a)). It creates a presumption of suitability for the selection requirements it covers ([Regulation 64(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/64#p2)), which must not be questioned without justification ([Regulation 64(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/64#p3)). Operators from other Member States cannot be obliged to be registered or certified in order to participate ([Regulation 64(9)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/64#p9)).

## Reducing the number of candidates

In restricted procedures, competitive procedures with negotiation, competitive dialogue and innovation partnerships, the authority may limit the number of candidates who meet the selection criteria that it invites to tender or to a dialogue ([Regulation 65(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p1)). To do so it must state in the contract notice or invitation to confirm interest the objective and non-discriminatory criteria or rules it will apply, the minimum number of candidates and, where applicable, the maximum ([Regulation 65(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p2)).

| Procedure                                                                            | Minimum number of candidates |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------- |
| Restricted procedure                                                                 | 5 ([Regulation 65(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p3))             |
| Competitive procedure with negotiation, competitive dialogue, innovation partnership | 3 ([Regulation 65(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p4))             |

The number invited must in any case be sufficient to ensure genuine competition ([Regulation 65(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p5)), and at least the minimum must be invited ([Regulation 65(6)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p6)). If fewer candidates meet the selection criteria and minimum levels of ability than the minimum number, the authority may continue by inviting those with the required capabilities ([Regulation 65(7)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p7)), but not operators that did not request to participate or candidates lacking the required capabilities ([Regulation 65(8)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/65#p8)).

The results of qualitative selection and of any reduction, with the names of selected and rejected candidates and the reasons, go into the authority’s procurement report ([Regulation 84(1)(b)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/84#p1-b)).

The grounds that may keep an operator out before selection is reached are explained in the [guide to exclusion grounds](https://procurelex.ie/guides/exclusion-grounds).
