# Award criteria and life-cycle costing

- URL: https://procurelex.ie/guides/award-criteria-and-life-cycle-costing
- Updated 2026-11-20
- Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte (Head of Public Sector at Closer), 2026-11-20
- Legal basis: Regulation 67(1), Regulation 67(2), Regulation 67(3), Regulation 67(5), Regulation 67(6), Regulation 67(7), Regulation 67(9), Regulation 67(11), Regulation 68(1), Regulation 68(3), Regulation 68(4), Regulation 68(5), Schedule 9

How the most economically advantageous tender is identified, which award criteria may be used and how they must be weighted, and how life-cycle costing is applied under Regulation 68 and Schedule 9.

The award criteria decide which tender wins. Regulation 67 sets one basis for every award, the most economically advantageous tender, and lays down what the criteria may cover, how they must be linked to the contract and how they must be weighted. Regulation 68 and Schedule 9 govern life-cycle costing, the way of measuring cost over the whole life of what is bought. This guide goes through both, in the order an authority drafts its tender documents and a tenderer reads them.

## Where award fits in the procedure

Contracts are awarded on the basis of criteria laid down in accordance with Regulations 67 to 69, once the authority has verified that the tender complies with the requirements of the notice and the procurement documents, that the tenderer is not excluded and meets the selection criteria, and, where applicable, that it meets the rules for reducing the number of candidates ([Regulation 56(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/56#p1)). Selection asks whether the operator can perform the contract; award asks which tender is best.

Even then, the authority may decide not to award the contract to the tenderer with the most economically advantageous tender where it has established that the tender does not comply with applicable obligations in the fields of environmental, social and labour law ([Regulation 56(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/56#p2), [Regulation 18(4)(a)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/18#p4-a)).

## One basis: the most economically advantageous tender

Without prejudice to any law in the State on the price of certain supplies or the remuneration of certain services, an authority must base the award of public contracts on the most economically advantageous tender ([Regulation 67(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p1)).

That tender is identified, from the authority’s point of view, on the basis of the price or cost, using a cost-effectiveness approach, including life-cycle costing in accordance with Regulation 68, and it may include the best price-quality ratio ([Regulation 67(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p2)). In practice there are three ways of applying it:

| Approach                 | What is compared                                                                                       | Provision    |
| ------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------ |
| Price or cost only       | The price, or the cost measured by a cost-effectiveness approach, including life-cycle costing         | [Regulation 67(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p2) |
| Best price-quality ratio | Price or cost together with qualitative, environmental or social criteria linked to the subject matter | [Regulation 67(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p2) |
| Fixed price or cost      | Quality only: the cost element is fixed and operators compete on quality criteria                      | [Regulation 67(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p4) |

## What the criteria may cover

The criteria for the best price-quality ratio may comprise, amongst other things ([Regulation 67(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p3)):

- quality, including technical merit, aesthetic and functional characteristics, accessibility, design for all users, social, environmental and innovative characteristics, and trading and its conditions ([Regulation 67(3)(a)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p3-a));
- the organisation, qualification and experience of the staff assigned to performing the contract, where the quality of those staff can have a significant impact on the level of performance ([Regulation 67(3)(b)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p3-b));
- after-sales service and technical assistance, and delivery conditions such as delivery date, delivery process and delivery period or period of completion ([Regulation 67(3)(c)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p3-c)).

The list is open: “amongst other things”. What makes any criterion lawful is its link to the subject matter and the safeguards below.

## The link to the subject matter

Award criteria are considered linked to the subject matter of the contract where they relate to the works, supplies or services in any respect and at any stage of their [life cycle](https://procurelex.ie/glossary/life-cycle), including factors involved in the specific process of production, provision or trading, or in a specific process for another stage of the life cycle ([Regulation 67(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p5)). The closing words of the paragraph read “where those factors do not form part of their material substance”. Article 67(3) of Directive 2014/24/EU, which it transposes, reads “even where”, as do the corresponding words for technical specifications ([Regulation 42(2)(b)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/42#p2-b)); the word “even” is missing from the Irish text. Read with the Directive, a factor in how something is produced or traded may be taken into account as linked to the contract whether or not it is part of what is physically delivered.

The same test of linkage is used for contract performance conditions ([Regulation 70(1)(a)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/70#p1-a)), and a label may be required as means of proof under the award criteria if the conditions of Regulation 43 are met ([Regulation 43(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/43#p1)). Test reports and certificates from a conformity assessment body may also be required as proof of conformity with award criteria ([Regulation 44(2)(b)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/44#p2-b)).

## Safeguards on every criterion

Award criteria must not confer an unrestricted freedom of choice on the authority ([Regulation 67(6)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p6)). They must ensure the possibility of effective competition, and be accompanied by specifications that allow the information provided by tenderers to be effectively verified, in order to assess how well the tenders meet the criteria ([Regulation 67(7)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p7)). In case of doubt, the authority must verify effectively the accuracy of the information and proof provided by tenderers ([Regulation 67(8)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p8)).

Where variants are authorised or required, the award criteria chosen must be capable of being applied both to variants meeting the minimum requirements and to conforming tenders that are not variants ([Regulation 45(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/45#p5)).

## Weighting

Unless the tender is identified on the basis of price alone, the authority must specify in the procurement documents the relative weighting it gives to each criterion ([Regulation 67(9)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p9)).

- The weighting may be expressed as a range with an appropriate maximum spread ([Regulation 67(10)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p10)).
- Where weighting is not possible for objective reasons, the authority must list the criteria in descending order of importance ([Regulation 67(11)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p11)).

The weighting matters later too. Where an electronic auction follows, the full initial evaluation uses the award criteria and the weighting fixed for them ([Regulation 35(9)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/35#p9)), and any ranges of weightings are reduced beforehand to a specified value ([Regulation 35(19)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/35#p19)).

## Life-cycle costing

Life-cycle costing measures cost over the [life cycle](https://procurelex.ie/glossary/life-cycle) of a product, service or works: all consecutive or interlinked stages, including research and development, production, trading, transport, use and maintenance, from raw material acquisition or generation of resources to disposal, clearance and end of service or utilisation ([Regulation 2(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/2#p1)).

### Which costs

To the extent relevant, life-cycle costing covers part or all of these costs ([Regulation 68(1)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p1)):

1. Costs borne by the authority or other users ([Regulation 68(1)(a)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p1-a)), including:
   - acquisition costs ([Regulation 68(1)(a)(i)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p1-a-i));
   - costs of use, such as consumption of energy and other resources ([Regulation 68(1)(a)(ii)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p1-a-ii));
   - maintenance costs ([Regulation 68(1)(a)(iii)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p1-a-iii));
   - end of life costs, such as collection and recycling ([Regulation 68(1)(a)(iv)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p1-a-iv)).
2. Costs imputed to environmental externalities linked to the product, service or works during its life cycle, provided their monetary value can be determined and verified ([Regulation 68(1)(b)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p1-b)). These may include the cost of greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutant emissions, and other climate change mitigation costs ([Regulation 68(2)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p2)).

### Conditions for valuing externalities

The method used to assess costs imputed to environmental externalities must ([Regulation 68(3)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p3)):

- be based on objectively verifiable and non-discriminatory criteria and, where it was not established for repeated or continuous application, not unduly favour or disadvantage certain economic operators ([Regulation 68(3)(a)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p3-a));
- be accessible to all interested parties ([Regulation 68(3)(b)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p3-b));
- require data that normally diligent economic operators, including those from third countries party to the GPA or other international agreements binding the European Union, can provide with reasonable effort ([Regulation 68(3)(c)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p3-c)).

### What the procurement documents must say

Where an authority uses a life-cycle costing approach, it must indicate in the procurement documents the data the tenderers are to provide and the method it will use to determine the life-cycle costs on the basis of that data ([Regulation 68(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p4)). A tenderer should be able to calculate its own life-cycle cost from the documents before it submits.

### Common methods made mandatory: Schedule 9

Whenever a common method for calculating life-cycle costs has been made mandatory by a legislative act of the European Union listed in Schedule 9, that method must be applied ([Regulation 68(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p5)). Schedule 9 lists one act: Directive 2009/33/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2009 ([Schedule 9](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/schedule-9)). Whether that Directive has since been amended at European Union level should be checked before relying on it.

## After the award

Any tenderer that has made an admissible tender may ask in writing to be told the characteristics and relative advantages of the tender selected and the name of the successful tenderer; the authority must answer as soon as possible and no later than 15 days after the request ([Regulation 55(2)(c)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/55#p2-c)). The written report on the procedure must give the name of the successful tenderer and the reasons why its tender was selected ([Regulation 84(1)(d)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/84#p1-d)). Notification of the decision and the standstill period are covered in the guide on [award and standstill](https://procurelex.ie/guides/award-and-standstill), and review in the guide on [remedies](https://procurelex.ie/guides/remedies).

## Checklist

- Decide the approach: price or cost only, best price-quality ratio, or fixed cost with quality competition.
- Link every criterion to the subject matter ([Regulation 67(5)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p5)) and make it verifiable ([Regulation 67(7)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p7)).
- State the weighting, a range, or at least the order of importance in the procurement documents ([Regulation 67(9)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p9), [Regulation 67(11)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/67#p11)).
- If costing over the life cycle, publish the data required and the method ([Regulation 68(4)](https://procurelex.ie/regulations/68#p4)), and check Schedule 9 for a mandatory method.
- If a tender looks abnormally low against these criteria, follow Regulation 69; see the guide on [abnormally low tenders](https://procurelex.ie/guides/abnormally-low-tenders).
